what about Thackery? a good player on his day



would the fans be happy with him?

Not on about just from a playing point of view. I couldn't imagine one rovers fan who would be happy with a signing like this, if you wrote a list of what you wouldn't want Paul king ticks every box..





(Now I really have made a rod for my own back if he ever did sign..)

No.

[iPaul[/i King?



I used to think that just because he played poorly in derbies, my judgement of him was negatively skewed. Then Wilf says in his diary that he had his [ibest[/i games against us. Was good once, I'm sure, but now has the impact of an 80-minuter, playing in short spells off the bench. The FC fans (well, some) love him but even his most ardent admirers are relieved, if not pleased, to see him go.



Bibb would be alright and and in line with our current recruitment strategy. Don't think he is OOC though and Wakefield have let a few go.



Thackray is the sort of player we need, but there are big doubts over his professionalism. His stats for 2009 aren't bad - compare with Fozzard for example on the SL site. A one year with strings and conditions attached might be okay - [imight[/i be okay.



Remember too that Lovegrove wasn't regarded by most as a prop going into the year. Mills has been anonymous, but was a steady member of the 17 throughout 2008. Plus Watts will be 20 during next season and 6 or 8 games would really help his development IMO.

I doubt King would go to you and even if he would he is not someone you need. He will be lucky to play for another SL club and could well be plying his trade a division down next season. Rumours abound he may be going to Celtic.



Thacks is a good player and it seems he has yet again fallen out with the coach. What the reasons behind it are i don't know but he is a good impact prop who can do a job in SL IF he can be sorted out.

Would only offer a 1 year deal because if problems arise it is easier to get rid.

We need at least 1 but hopefully 2 proven front row forwards. You need 4 for every match plus injury cover. We've now only got Vella who's proven, but he does get injured.We should either use Mills or get rid.

Whats wrong with Wheeldon?

Good point; I forgot about him

We still need another one or two I.M.O.

Good post,



The thing with thackrey is how many chances do you give a player before you realise he's just that way out and will never change. His comments when leaving Leeds aimed at the coach summed up his attitude and he seems to have gone a similar way with FC's heirarchy. FC gave him a way back into SL and he seems to have thrown that back at them so if i was an SL team I stay well clear regardless of what the pro's are in relation to his playing abilities.

liam watts is back at kr now after his loan, so maybe give him a few games, after all he did show promise

Wouldnt sign either. Id probably go for feather from cas and someone else. Im not exactly sure who is available, possibly Sam Moa. As with the right coaching he could be just the type of forward we are looking for.