If Calders is out for 6 weeks I hope Agar's only tough choice is mash or chips for tea.

Steady on there. He's had two loan spells with us and only one stand out game. Yes, he played very well on Saturday, but 'world class potential' is going a little far.



He might make a good SL player in years to come, but on the basis of one performance it's important not to get carried away. Thorman had a good game against Bradford.

not really when we have our own youngnster in Hall who counts on the cap and we are loaning him out to loan a player in. why not just play Hall on the wing?



however he did have a good game last night

May have had a good game but Hall should be on the wing when he comes back...But we know that wont happen as Agars treatment of Hall is disgracefull.....

just wondering if hall has played for widnes yet ?

Let's not get carried away, he has had one good game and we would need to see more of the same for us to start offering a contract. I’ve thought he has been ok in the other games I’ve seen him and let’s face it, it would be easy to stand out in the Hull team at present.



We should be concentrating on the fact that a loan player who can't get game time in the Leeds team was our stand out player.

He may look good is a very poor team but world class????

















Leeds must be over the moon at the way you are developing one of their youngesters

Yes a couple of games I think. Kicked a few goals. Playing centre with Penny as his winger.

just think he showed real potential...and as i have highlighted he could have world class potential...i never said is world class. I think he is a brill player

I believe Broughton has a great attitude and works hard on his game, thats half the battle.

Hope he keeps improving.

Barrie Mac alluded to this the other week. He has had a lot of knocks during his life/career but has also worked really hard on his game and this has gone a long way to getting him to where he is now.



A few of our players could learn a thing or two about applying themselves and working hard.

I agree, Hall is a better player and should be here.

Imagine what Agar would have said if was Hall that (lost the ball), he would have been crusified.