i meant the st helens v leeds on you tube

I posted the links to the Morley incident on the Sam Moa thread, both cases point to why big Sam should be available for selection next week. Had that game not been on sky, it would have been play on with only a stopage for the injured player.

No worries dude

The slight difference is that Moa probably meant to hit the shoulder, but missed and got him straight on the jaw instead. I don't think he meant to do it, but it was reckless.

go on the Tube of You and look at Rangi Chase V Sinfield from last year exactly the same kind of hit, what was the outcome of that? Not sure if it was even a penalty was it?

No the rules haven't changed.

Bailey plays for Leeds = No Charge

Sam plays for Hull =

As has been said by lots of posters already hits like those happen all the time and it's rarely even a penalty let alone a red card. If this gets anything other than a not guilty then it's a disgrace.

To me, that looks worse than the one Moa did...

That video clip of Bailey on Faasavalu (sp?) is very similar to the Moa on Rinaldi challenge. Both players go in to make the big hit and make unintentional contact with the head due to the ball-runner dipping in. If the Bailey occurance was given as 'no-charge' then the same should happen to Moa. As someone stated earlier, it's an almost perfect precedent.

Hopefully the club will bring this case up at Moa's disciplinary.

whatever happens it wont alter the fact that Silverwood and Bentham will have nothing done to them> Their incomptence which they show week after week will go unmentioned.I hope against hope that this incident should wake up everyone and make them sort these refs out. We pay bloody good money to watch a sport not a ref. Perhaps if they stopped coaching on the pitch and got on with reffing this problem wouldnt arise.

Jonathon Walker (Castleford) on Luke Burgess (Leeds) 13.8.10



Have a look at this incident on YT and tell me how this differs from Sam's case. Note the explanation as to the reason why Walker was not charged



Case Number ON/599/10

Name Jonathan Walker

Club Castleford

Shirt Number 31

Match Castleford v Leeds

Competition Super League

Date 13/08/10

Incident considered High tackle on Luke Burgess in 79th minute

Decision No charge

Details of Charge / Reason for NF Player used legal shoulder charge. Point of collision accidental

According to someone on Twitter, Tommy Lee has pleaded guilty and takena 2 match ban. Fair play to him if so, although I don't really think he had a case.