Do we have to play Widnes every time, Saints Wigan etc? We could have a random draw or base it on league standings either current or fianl standings from previous year?



Even a random draw would throw up the odd match to keep the neutrals intertested.

A random draw still wouldn't be fair for a single game decider - current standings would be good though, it would be difficult to say that wasn't fair unless people were obviously throwing games to get a better chance of winning.



In fact, go with the current standings, and a prize for each game? I'm not sure if this was what you meant originally, but a prize for each game would be a real incentive, especially given the financial situation at the moment.

Hey woah woah woah, lets not be agreeing with anyone over us having widnes at MM.



Please remember, whilst saints and wigan fans are moaning about playing them every year, likewise leeds and bradford(before they went ) we, warrington, have been making up the numbers on the magic weekends, we've had , non derby games against, salford, huddersfield and hull kr, we weren't even televised in 2008 as teh first game of the entire weekend.



And fan wise, we've still turned up in numbers, made noise and been the centre of attention, and spent loads of money.



We've got our derby back, which we've been deprived of, dont be taking it back off us just cos widnes are .

So what is the point you’re trying to make is resting players (Salford/London) a good idea or not? For ne it’s a matter of how many and when, not having a good few on the injury list helps too.

I guess it means different things to different people - I don't really care for the Widnes derby, as for the vast majority of my time following Warrington the two clubs have been in different leagues. Plus you have to admit it is not fair to be awarding league points based on an extra fixture of local derbies that are not very balanced.

I would want wigan at MM- we beat them more than widnes any way.

I'd sooner be the best and recognised as such by one and all because we have operated from a level playing field.



Having travelled back to Bank Quay from Euston in '75 on the late late train, with the Widnes team in the front coach with 'our' cup I also support the Widnes is our Derby campaign and I'm enjoying being on top for now but two wins a year is enough unless we draw them in the cup.



This seasons' Magic weekend was a good dayout despite the match which was a none event

Why not just get rid of the Magic Weekend altogether. It's a pointless exercise anyway, especially if you play it in Manchester.



Take the two Challenge semi-finals on the road in order to spread the word if needs be.

I think the pretense that it was spreading the game has been given up now. What it is is a massive fully-televised event that probably earns Sky loads in advertising, so it is very unlikely to be dropped even if we wanted it to.

Scrap the Magic Weekend in its current format.

Reduce SL to 12 teams playing each other home and away then splitting into top six and bottom six for a further 10 games each. Top of the league after 32 games are champions.

Re-arrange the Challenge Cup so that the 12 SL clubs and the remaining 4 'non-SL' clubs all meet over one weekend at one venue, similar to the current SL Magic Weekend.



All clubs get to play 32 games. No farcical extra fixture. End of the season consists of huge game after huge game which is ideal for Sky. Best team over the whole season are champions, not the team that can string 4 or 5 wins together at the end. The Challenge Cup gets a massive weekend event.

I understand the need to perhaps revamp the competition but offered my suggestion on MW as a tweak on the current system till a more appealing radical solution can be found.



I think that your league system has merit, but, I'm not sure about the cup. I know that it is a romantic notion but everyone should have a chance of winning it.

Batley, Hunslet or Doncaster have no chance whatsoever of reaching Wembley and contesting a final, but under the system I described they all have the chance of reaching the last 16 and playing Leeds, Wigan or ourselves in the Millenium Stadium, Etihad, etc. Surely a massive incentive for Championship clubs to do well in the cup, plus they could draw Widnes and get to play in the last eight too.