I'd have another look at it, If I hadn't walked in and hit delete before I'd even shut the front door.

Looks fine to me. I had another look this morning, Coley went in at the leg, which was fine, as he made contact, Solomona twisted his leg slightly, nothing really to do with the tacklers. The combination of timing was the issue, Coley had committed to the tackle, Solomona had committed to turning in the tackle. End of Story

[urlhttp://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b012tmh4/Rugby_League_Challenge_Cup_2011_QuarterFinal_Warrington_v_Wigan/[/url



So you dont have to watch the whole thing again, jump in at 1:22:00

It was a difficult one to judge. But because Coley is a very dirty player, I'd say he went into the tackle to intentionally hurt, and cause injury to Solomona.

Don't think it was too bad..I think Coley (although he can swing a few at times) was just trying to stop Solamona's progress.. It wasn't like the Lima one at Leeds where he just dived at the players knee...

I do think there will be more injuries with this type of tackle though.. I suppose we have to live with it..

The reason this is being made a big deal, is because Wigan have been injuring players with these type of tackles all season.

Really can you name all these bad injuries and who made them?

Well come on then NAME THEM.

My first reaction was it was filth, mainly because Solo was having such an impact on the game and Wigan do have a rep for it. Having seen the replay it doesn't look bad at all - just unlucky I guess.

Having watched it again on iplayer... there was bugger all wrong. What was Coley supposed to do? Let him make another 10 yards? If you watch it Solomona was still moving so someone had to grab his legs.

Still waiting: It must be long list .