Point out the opposition again in that semi final your referring too ? Is it the side thats currently bottom of SL and have looked woeful this year including 2 recent pastings by us and Leeds ?



We could have played Alex Murphy at scrum half and would have still beat them.

Am not saying its right or wrong am saying its that game which he has based this idea on.

Can't believe that Richie is not playing tomorrow, I really truly can't believe it.



Mr Smith chased Richie and brought him to the club and then not to play him in the biggest game of the season .............

Sorry but for me this is a mistake.

Similar disappointments have happened to Sinfield and McGuire at Leeds when they were about the same age.



I'm sure they used it as a motivation going forward. I think McGuire scored 38 tries the following season - money now on Myler to be top scorer next year.



It must be devestating for Richie at the moment but I'm sure he will have the opportunity again in the not too distant future.



Lets not forget Mike Cooper has missed out as well despite his excellent recent form.

Seems I'm in the minority on here but I think Smith has got a terribly difficult decision correct.



Myler is already a very good player with years of improvement still ahead of him, but I have yet to see him display enough composure and correct decision-making when under pressure. Combine that with his organisational skills not yet being that of a top class half-back and I completely understand why this choice has been made.



I don't believe it's any deficiency in Myler's defensive technique that's contributed significantly to this. I'm far more worried about Senior running against Briers than I was about Delaney against Myler.



Expect to see Clarke at half-back more than Monaghan.

Well, I got that completely wrong.



Regardless of the result tomorrow, I hope there's no knee jerking e.g. if we lose; Smith blew it, or, if we win; end of Myler's career.



One thing is absolutely certain; we're going to find out very soon just how serious this 'team' ethic is. If that means anything at all, win or lose tomorrow, how the players react to it in the coming weeks is going to be very revealing. I should say that the fact that I'm unsure about the call is no reflection on the players who got the nod, I'm sure they'll do us proud.



I would play Myler but what do I know, less than Smith, that's for sure. Hope I'm wrong again.

You have got to hand it to Mr Smith he is not afraid to make a decison which he feels is correct.

When Mr Smith first came here wasn't Lee Breirs dropped and rumours that he would be moving on, and then we sold Martin Gleeson.

Very surprised by this. Personally I think you look a much better team with Monas at 9. From what i've seen of the 3 players Myler would be in my team before both Clarke and Higham aswell, cant understand this decision & it could end up costing you...

He could just stay in his hotel room and sulk but fair play to him he's not and he's taking it all in with the other players.

Forget in TS we trust, this is his biggest mistake so far, i don't think it's the right call.

It will come off. Che is GOD.

Have to wait and see.