I was at the game so haven't had the benefit of watching it over and over again, it looked debatable, from the big screen, I've seen them given (ala last night) and I've seen them not.



ATEOTD it didn't matter, but gave Wire something to build on in the second half, they failed.

You should have stopped after the first 6 words. The rest just makes you look a bit silly. 3 or 4 yards over the line???? He was on the line at best but with the tackle still moving it was play on as long as there was no pulling, only pushing.

Morleys arm <removes P&B specks>



I think it was just (and i mean just) his arm, just below the shoulder socket

BUT

i think he'll get away with it, not because there is an RFL conspiracy(see Lima, Wigan forum) but because his arm is pointing behind him, ie not stuck out to wrap around his head, no forward momentum of the arm, i genuinely believe Morley thinks his tackle was legit.

Silverwood had a good game. Sure, he missed a few things both ways - all refs do and it must be down to the speed of the game.



Get over it and move on.

Thats the most sensible post on this I have read

IF your fishing for a bite, then so be it...but....



Morley shouldnt have been sent off, dont be pathetic, the guy sidstepped,and it was Moz's shoulder that smashed him.



And double movement?? It was all one movement. You watch that at normal speed and there was no way Hodgson stopped AT ALL and then proceeded to plonk the ball down.



Like a carp to sweetcorn iv took that i know, but meh!







Silverwoods always iffy, but we were well and truly beaten, mainly down to lack of creativity in out department.

thought he had a decent game, i too haven't watched the replay but would like to see morley's great hit again as it looked bad at the ground.both wires tries looked contentious at first but dont think there was much in it to be honest.

other than that the constant high shots when it was clear warrington were beaten was pretty annoying.

I'll be honest I thought he was back in the field of play rather further than the line, but as you say the tackle as seen by the official was still moving and I agree there wasn't any pulling,but what ever happened to the ruling that when other players join in from the defending side the tackle is called?

Yeah couldn't agree more, once we were beat you didn't need to continue with this tactic

momentum. It was all fluid.

Another one taking the win with grace. If in your wildest dreams no other ref would have called held after the fifth giants player and third wire player got involved and hodgson was as rigid as flag pole. Then you've got issues.



Why can't giants fans see that every single wire fan is saying the best team won.



Some of the bull poop is on pie eater level I'm afraid

Well it's not like you can say anything else is it? It's the reasons that i'm finding amusing



Last week's loss was the drummers fault according to someone on here.